The following is a perfect example of the kind of thing we at RU have been contending with ever since we started investigating certain stories in the UFOlogy arena. It is also a perfect example of the kind of threats we have been facing for daring to question the veracity of some of those stories and the people telling them.
The public announcement of our intent to publish our latest findings was made in the RU forum earlier this month, on the 2nd July. However, many behind the scenes already suspected what was coming a number of weeks before the actual announcement was made. In some cases, we made sure they knew
Still, when I received the following email from Ryan on the 26th June, there was no reason to suspect something untoward was in the works:
From: Ryan [ryguy@realityuncovered.com]
Sent: 26 June 2007 05:09
To:
sbroadbent@realityuncovered.comSubject: [Fwd: Meet?]
Attachments: Meet_ (1.62 KB)
looks like ******** been drinking. Look what he inadvertently sent me. lol
-Ry
From: ********
Sent: 26 June 2007 04:32
To:
ryguy@realityuncovered.comSubject: Meet?
Will you still be near Argonne in a few days?
Confused, I replied to Ryan. His response follows mine:
From: "Stephen Broadbent" <sbroadbent@realityuncovered.com>
To: "'Ryan'" <ryguy@realityuncovered.com>
Sent: 6/26/07 6:29 AM
Subject: RE: [Fwd: Meet?]
Haha!
Where is Argonne, sounds like France lol
From: Ryan Dube [ryguy@realityuncovered.com]
Sent: 26 June 2007 13:41
To: Stephen Broadbent
Subject: RE: [Fwd: Meet?]
Lol...it is actually a huge u.s. National lab...
We discussed it briefly on the phone later that night, but came to the conclusion that the email was more than likely sent to Ryan by mistake and we left it at that. After all, Ryan hadn't been out of his home State in months and had no immediate plans to either. Not long after making our "impending update" announcement on the 2nd July however, we realised the email most certainly was NOT sent to Ryan by mistake. Later that same day, Ryan received the following email:
Date: Mon, 2 Jul 2007 10:11:51 -0400
From: ********
Reply-To: ********
Subject: GhostRaven:PRIVATE
To:
ryguy@realityuncovered.comPrivate...not for sharing:
We could meet at the same library GR used to go-on-line to generate the
joke-hoax if/when you get back to the Holiday Inn Express.
But why did you use your name to register?
It seems you must have at least 80% of the story; Dan has 5%; M***
P******** has 1%; P***** has 3%; I only have 1%.
The data for the *.mil servers didn't (originally) come from ******** BTW.
I also do not believe the claimed number, nor understand why DOJ would
lie to me. But I think they did.
You can imagine the surprise we felt at reading that! For one thing, the email implied a prior correspondence, yet none had taken place. Because of this, I first thought the sender had made the same mistake as he had with the first email, i.e. sent it to the wrong person. As will be seen in other emails, it quickly became apparent that this was not the case.
"GhostRaven", as most people are probably aware, was a hoax played out at ATS in the days before the email above was sent. The sender clearly implied a knowledge of the actual location used by the GhostRaven hoaxer to generate the hoax, and wanted to meet Ryan at that same location, implying that Ryan also knew. The obvious question has to be; how could he know that? The sender also tries to imply that Ryan was staying at a Hotel in the area and was even questioning him on why he used his real name to book the hotel! The last paragraph illustrated that the email was indeed for Ryan, referring as it did to the alleged high number of military servers that had been visiting the GR thread at ATS (Ryan had replied to an email forwarded by Dan that mentioned those .mil servers).
Needless to say, it was apparent that the sender of the email was in some way trying to implicate Ryan in the GhostRaven hoax, without actually realising he was implicating himself! Ryan can easily prove where he was on the dates in question, can the sender of the email? Regardless of anything else, the sender clearly knew much more about GR than your average casual observer.
Ryan was incensed. He included me and one other in his reply:
From:
ryguy@realityuncovered.comSent: 02 July 2007 15:41
To: ********
Cc:
sbroadbent@realityuncovered.com; ********@********.com
Subject: Re: GhostRaven:PRIVATE
>
> But why did you use your name to register?
>
Unless you're talking about my recent registration for the 20 tokens for 1
pizza at Chucky Cheese, I've no clue what you're going on about. I would like
a full explanation of that one line - or I will simply save us all the time
and forward this email to everyone and their mother who you've likely bcc'd on
this anyway, and explain to everyone what's likely going on here - that ******** is making up more stories again.
I'm tempted to do it now, instead of waiting for another round of your
circular logic. As far as I'm concerned, you can go straight to hell, ********.
Assuming you aren't already there. I'm not interested in your emails full of
lies and fiction anymore.
I've cc'd Steve and ******** for transparency.
-Ryan
the "23 yr old", insecure, bling bling maker
The next reply wasn't long in coming (Emphasis added):
Well. Thank god I did say Private.
No, no one got copied. I trust you will at least honor that, as I have said...not a single message has been bcc'd.
The quote was not about you...you DO know who is was about. In fact, you were the one who "warned me' about the guy. And, there were two other emails you did not get, so you do not have the context.
The Calumet Holiday Inn near Argonne told me Ryan Dube had just checked
out. Call them. They say they remember you. I called them because a very
nice lady said you were there. I assumed you were Ghost Raven, because
the Library from where the emails were sent is several blocks away.
Also, several of hius phrases are identical to yours. But, I did not hire a
forensic analyst, so I could be wrong.
I have never lied to you, nor anyone, and never will.
I am not making up anything.
For sure this is incomplete.
I do note that you have said very, very harsh things about me on your site.
You can't get more specific than that! As you can see above, the sender gave us the actual name of the hotel Ryan was supposed to have checked in at, so we looked up the details and immediately contacted the hotel.
Unsurprisingly, they had
no record of a "Ryan Dube" on file and
no one remembered him. Notice again, the sender shows that he knows
exactly the location of the library used by the GhostRaven hoaxer...
Ryan replied:
From: Ryan [mailto:ryguy@realityuncovered.com]
Sent: Monday, July 02, 2007 7:31 PM
To: ********
Subject: Re: GhostRaven:PRIVATE
Funny - I called them and they have no record of a "Ryan Dube". How
about we have a chat with the "very nice" lady who is making false
claims about me.
Calumet Holiday Inn - 18 mi from Argonne:
12800 S. ASHLAND AVE
CALUMET PARK, IL 60643 UNITED STATES
Hotel Front Desk: 1-708-3892600 | Hotel Fax: 1-708-3898400
Not only the "very nice lady" is making thos claims Ryan, the sender above says he contacted the hotel
personally. Let's not forget what he said in his last paragraph above:
"I am not making up anything" No, of course not...

The final email followed the next day. It was a lengthy email and I have snipped the information at the end of the email. We don't want to make it too obvious just yet

From: ********
To: "Ryan" <ryguy@realityuncovered.com>
Sent: 7/3/07 9:20 AM
Subject: RE: GhostRaven:PRIVATE
Interesting.
I had the call made by a research assistant, and then I called back, too.
Hi ********,
Here is the number for the Holiday Inn Express in Calumet Park, Illinois
: 708-389-2600
Amy
The lady said she remembered a very nice Ryan Dube. She was unable, she said, to connect me, because you had already checked out. I asked her to please check the records, and tell me when you had been there, she said sure...then put me on hold for 5 minutes. Her Manager came on the line...another very nice lady. That one said there was no record of your stay, but she, too remembered. She did say, however, that perhaps her memory was "confused" because there had been three other calls (one was surely my research assistant, who was calling all the hotels near the library) for Ryan Dube. She did say, unasked, that there was a Ryan M. Dube listed in the phone book...was that the person I wanted? I said, no.
Hey, you were not there, Ryan Dube is a very common name, there just happens to also be one living in the area (but different Area Code than the hotel, which I found odd...why would the second Manager have done that...looked in a different suburb when I had not asked?).
There's a word for all of the above over here:
Balderdash!
Let's have a look at the events as they transpired:
22nd June
GhostRaven registers at ATS from a library in Argonne and begins posting.
26th June
Ryan receives a strange email asking if he will be staying in Argonne.
26th June
GhostRaven confesses and is banned from ATS.
2nd July
RU post announcement.
2nd July
Second email is received clearly attempting to implicate Ryan in a hoax.
For me, the clearest indication that the sender of the emails was attempting to either a)frame Ryan in a hoax or b)illustrate to him what he could do if pushed, was the very first email sent out of the blue on the 26th June. Why send that email in the first place if not to lay a foundation for everything else that may follow? The sender had first hand knowledge of the GR hoax while it was in progress and had also displayed a keen interest in the GR information throughout. If he didn't create the GhostRaven hoax I strongly suspect he knows who did.
The strongest clue lies in this piece I snipped from the email above:
I will be willing to call you, and or Skype, and read you the GhostRaven phrases and odd words that are right out of your emails to me...however, they are only what I remember...so it is quite possible you will easily disabuse me of them being unique. A couple are very interesting, though.
"Right out of your emails to me..."
Can you say "setup"?
Cheers,
Zep